Short answer: All three claim up to 2 years of storage life, so that isn’t the difference. The real differences are dose and what else each one claims to do. STA-BIL Storage is the plain stabilizer: 1 oz per 2.5 gallons, the cheapest per gallon treated in common sizes, and made for fresh fuel going into storage. Sea Foam Motor Treatment is mostly a cleaner that also stabilizes, at a heavier 1 oz per gallon, so it costs the most per gallon. Star Tron is an enzyme treatment at 1 oz per 6 gallons that also claims to disperse water and rejuvenate old fuel, which no engine maker we checked endorses. Whichever you pick, engine makers are more cautious than any label: Toro says about 6 months, and Honda says 90 days in the machine.

We compared the makers’ own product pages and engine makers’ manuals on November 19, 2026. We did not lab-test any of these products.

Side by side: what each maker claims

  STA-BIL Storage Sea Foam Motor Treatment Star Tron (Classic Gas / Small Engine)
Claimed storage life Up to 24 months Up to 2 years Up to 2 years
Storage dose 1 oz per 2.5 gal 1 oz per gal 1 oz per 6 gal
Must go in fresh fuel? Yes (“use only with fresh fuel”) Yes (“add when fuel is fresh”; won’t restore old fuel) Not required; claims it “can help rejuvenate old, sub-spec fuel”
Other claims Removes water to prevent corrosion; cleans carburetors and injectors; no alcohol Cleans fuel and oil systems; adds lubricity; works in gas and diesel Enzyme formula; disperses water as submicron droplets; helps prevent phase separation
Ethanol fuel Works in ethanol and non-ethanol gas, up to E85 Safe with ethanol-blended gas, including E10 “Works in all engines and all fuels”
After adding Run engine 5 minutes Run until treated fuel reaches carburetor or injectors Add just before each fill-up

Cost per gallon treated (prices checked November 19, 2026)

Product Amazon price Treats (maker’s ratio) Cost per gallon treated
STA-BIL Storage, 32 oz $13.58 80 gal $0.17
Star Tron Enzyme Fuel Treatment, 8 oz $15.68 48 gal $0.33
STA-BIL Storage, 10 oz $8.99 25 gal $0.36
Sea Foam Motor Treatment, 16 oz × 3 $29.99 48 gal $0.62
Star Tron Concentrated Formula, 32 oz $22.28 512 gal $0.04, but see below

Star Tron’s Concentrated Formula is 1 oz per 16 gallons, according to its listing. That’s built for boat tanks. Dosing a 1-gallon can would take about 1/16 of an ounce, which is hard to measure, so most small-engine owners are better off with the 8 oz small-engine bottle.

A bottle doesn’t last forever once opened. Gold Eagle says STA-BIL is good for 2 years after opening, and Honda notes that all stabilizers have a shelf life. A 32 oz bottle of STA-BIL treats 80 gallons; if you only treat a 2.5-gallon can a few times a year, the 10 oz bottle may be the better buy even at a higher cost per gallon.

Amazon prices change often, and some listings are sold by third-party sellers. Check the product page before you buy.

What the engine makers say about stabilizer

The labels say 2 years. The people who build the engines say less:

So a stabilizer is best treated as a few months of insurance for fuel in your can and tank, not a 2-year guarantee. For off-season storage, follow your engine manual, which may say drain.

Which one to pick

How to stabilize fuel correctly

  1. Buy fresh fuel and add stabilizer at the pump or as soon as you get home, at the maker’s ratio. All three makers and Toro agree the fuel must be fresh.
  2. Fill the can or tank nearly full. Gold Eagle says 95% full to limit condensation.
  3. Run the engine for 5 to 10 minutes so treated fuel reaches the carburetor (5 minutes per Gold Eagle; 10 minutes per Toro and Honda).
  4. Mark the date on the can and on the opened stabilizer bottle.

Frequently asked questions

Which fuel stabilizer lasts the longest?

On their own pages, all three makers claim up to 2 years: STA-BIL says up to 24 months, and Sea Foam and Star Tron each say up to 2 years. Engine makers are more cautious. Toro’s snowthrower manual says stabilizer keeps newly bought fuel fresh for up to 6 months, and Honda says not to leave gas in its snow blowers more than 90 days of inactivity even with stabilizer.

Can a fuel stabilizer fix old gas?

STA-BIL and Sea Foam both say to add their product to fresh fuel, and Sea Foam says it won’t restore old fuel. Toro and Honda say stabilizer will not make stale fuel fresh again. Star Tron is the outlier: its page says it can help rejuvenate old, sub-spec fuel. We have not tested that claim.

How much STA-BIL per gallon?

Gold Eagle’s directions are 1 ounce of STA-BIL Storage per 2.5 gallons of fuel, added to fresh fuel, then run the engine for 5 minutes.

How much Sea Foam per gallon for storage?

Sea Foam’s directions for stabilizing fuel are 1 ounce per gallon, added when the fuel is fresh, then run the engine long enough for treated fuel to reach the carburetor or injectors.

Can I use these in ethanol-free gas?

Yes. Gold Eagle says STA-BIL works in ethanol and non-ethanol gasoline, Sea Foam says it is safe with ethanol-blended gasoline including E10 and sells it for gasoline engines generally, and Star brite says Star Tron works in all fuels.

Sources